Why coaches should focus on player growth over what the scoreboard says

By Eric Smith | Posted 1/13/2017

If you want to win at a high level stop focusing on winning.

Many of you had to re-read that last sentence twice, didn’t you? But I mean it! Allow me to explain.

When you focus on the scoreboard, you are using a results oriented mindset. You are merely comparing yourself to your opponent.

Let’s be honest. How much control do we really have over our opponent’s level of talent, effort or preparation? The answer is absolutely none. The problem is that a winning or scoreboard mindset conflicts with all of the latest research regarding peak performance.

Performance psychologists would tell us is that to maximize performance we should focus only on the things that we can control. When an athlete feels in control, they will not only play more freely, they will play harder with more emotion and passion. More importantly, they will work harder in practice, and during the off season. They will also be more enabled to overcome adversity and bounce back from failure.

The Positive Coaching Alliance (PCA) is a national advocacy organization whose mission is to change the culture of youth sports. They promote the idea that the key to maximizing performance in athletics is to move from a Results (scoreboard) mindset to a Mastery (growth) mindset. This mindset focuses more on growing as a player instead of results at the end of a game.

PCA uses the "ELM Tree" acronym to help coaches and athletes focus solely on 3 key elements that an athlete can fully control:

  • Effort
  • Learning
  • Mistakes

Effort through preparation and hustle.

Learning with an emphasis on having a teachable mind set and being a student of the game.

Mistakes are ok because as long as the athlete doesn’t lay blame and point fingers, he will learn and grow from his failures.

PCA even goes as far as teaching athletes how to "flush" mistakes by using a physical ritual immediately after mistakes were made, such as wiping the forehead or flicking your wrist as if to wipe it off.  The athlete is essentially saying to themselves “No sweat…I’ve got this!"

Effort, Learning and embracing Mistakes are 3 key facets of growth that an athlete can control.  Feeling in control not only empowers athletes to play more freely, but also to work harder, improve endurance and overcome adversity. Doing so leads to mastery!

If you’re an athlete wanting to be your absolute best, or a coach wanting to maximize the potential of your athletes, then incorporate these concepts and know that the scoreboard will take care of itself.

Legendary UCLA Basketball Coach John Wooden suggested, "If you're victorious vs. a lessor opponent or if you get lucky and win, are you a Winner? Do your best and lose and you’re a loser? I don’t see it that way...”

Here are 2 tips on how you can create a culture of growth for yourself or your team.

First, set growth oriented goals, not performance oriented or results goals. 

According to Nick Saban, these were the team goals of the 2003 National Champion LSU Tigers as laid out by their senior leaders:   

Be a Team – Together Everyone Accomplishes More.

Work to Dominate Your Opponent.

Positively Affect Our Teammates.

Individual Responsibility for Self

Be Champions On and Off the Field.

None of these goals say anything about Wins and Losses, do they?

Second, emphasize and reward effort and actions, not results.

For an athlete, this would mean to take pride in the preparation, the hard work and the effort that you put forth toward improving your craft. For a coach this would mean acknowledging an athlete’s actions and efforts, not results. For example, if one of your receivers, who is being used as a decoy on a particular play runs hard and occupies the correct defender, then that should be recognized and rewarded just as much, if not more than the receiver who catches the ball and scores a touchdown.

If you want to be a champion, then focus on growth. Embrace the process involved in the journey to mastery, and let the results speak for themselves.

Eric a former NCAA Division 1 Quarterback and High School Football Coach.  Eric is the owner and director of Winning Edge Skills, an On-Line Quarterback Training Academy where he coaches and mentors aspiring quarterbacks. He also hosts Quarterback / Receiver Skill Development Camps throughout Northern CA, Nevada and Oregon.

Eric is also a certified Leadership Speaker, Trainer and Coach for the John Maxwell Leadership Team

To connect with Coach Smith visit http://winningedgeskills.com/ or email him at winningedgeqb@gmail.com follow on Twitter at @winningedgeqbr or Facebook at https://www.facebook.com/winningedgeskills

Share